I then gave it the data from my Popper/book example without any
hint that it was about books

hakank:
'''
pos(f(1,[camoes,lusiadas,asa])).
pos(f(2,[pessoa,mensagem,asa])).
pos(f(3,[vergilioFerreira,contaCorrente,asa])).
pos(f(4,[saramago,levantadoDoChao,caminho])).
pos(f(5,[saramago,memorialDoConvento,caminho])).
pos(f(6,[eca,osMaias,lello])).
pos(f(7,[eca,aReliquia,lello])).

neg(f(1,[camoes,lusiadas,caminho])).
neg(f(1,[saramago,lusiadas,asa])).
neg(f(2,[pessoa,lusiadas,asa])).
neg(f(3,[vergilioFerreira,levantadoDoChao,asa])).
neg(f(4,[saramago,contaCorrente,caminho])).
'''

GPT4:
'''
The pattern is that the function f takes an integer as input and returns a list with three elements, where the first element is an author, the second element is a book written by that author, and the third element is the publisher of the book. Each integer corresponds to a specific author, book, and publisher combination.

For example:

Input: 1, Output: [camoes, lusiadas, asa]
Input: 2, Output: [pessoa, mensagem, asa]
Input: 3, Output: [vergilioFerreira, contaCorrente, asa]
Input: 4, Output: [saramago, levantadoDoChao, caminho]
Input: 5, Output: [saramago, memorialDoConvento, caminho]
Input: 6, Output: [eca, osMaias, lello]
Input: 7, Output: [eca, aReliquia, lello]
'''

That it clearly correct, but how did GPT4 know that it was about books?
There was no hints about that in the problem.

hakank:
'''
Excellent. Have you seen this example before? If so, where?
'''

GPT4:
'''
As an AI language model, I cannot recall specific examples from previous interactions. However, I have seen a wide range of example problems during my training, and the problem you presented is a similar format to the ones you provided before. It's a pattern-recognition problem where the function maps an input integer to a specific output list containing author, book, and publisher information.
'''

Hakan Kjellerstrand
'''
But how did you know that it was author, title and publisher?
'''

GPT4:
'''
My apologies for the confusion. I made an assumption based on the structure of the data provided in the examples. However, you are right that I cannot be certain of the exact meaning of the elements in the list. The more accurate description of the problem is that the function maps an input integer to a specific output list containing three elements, without making any assumption about the meaning of those elements.
'''

(GPT4 might have recognized some of the names and titles and drew the
correct conclusion about this. And it seems that this is what GPT4 did...)

hakank:
'''
Who is vergilioFerreira?
'''

GPT4:
'''
Vergílio Ferreira (1916–1996) was a Portuguese writer and philosopher. He is known for his works in existentialist literature and is considered one of the most significant Portuguese novelists of the 20th century. Among his numerous works, his novel "Aparição" (1959) gained significant recognition. "Conta-Corrente" is another one of his well-known works, a series of five volumes of diaries, written between 1969 and 1993. Ferreira's writings often explore themes such as human existence, individualism, and the search for meaning.
'''

Well done, GPT4!